K
Kimberly, Florida
October 15, 2025
It's huge and I love it!!
Okay, so I knew that this cookie sheet said that it was x-large, and I reviewed the dimensions before ordering, however, I don’t think I truly understood what I was getting. I thought this was the same size, or slightly larger, as another cookie sheet and rack we already had. I simply wanted to double that, so I had an extra one. This cookie sheet is twice the size of any other sheet pan I have, and what is probably standard in most kitchens. I have a standard sized oven in my kitchen, and this pan takes up a whole rack in the oven. It is a big boy! This is the pan you break out for the school bake sale, or the holiday cookies. I like using it for the one-pan sheet pan meals. I can put my asparagus or Brussel sprouts, my chicken, and my potatoes all on the same pan and make them all together without having to dirty up multiple pans. Everything cooks evenly, toasts and browns to perfection. This pan is also ideal if you like making whole fish or large slabs of ribs and you’ll still have plenty of room to throw on potatoes to bake. There is a lot of room on this pan to make a lot of things. Unfortunately, this is not going to fit in most home kitchen dishwashers. It is, however, quite easy to clean. We had some cheese baked onto it from some garlic cheese bread we made, and it came right off with just hot water slightly heating the pan back up, no issue at all and very little scrubbing. Same with sauced meat we made that had baked on, it came clean so quickly. The biggest problem I have with this item is figuring out where to store it when not in use. None of my kitchen cabinets or drawers are large enough to accommodate this cookie sheet, accept the drawer under the oven, and it barely fits there. We’ve just been keeping it in the oven. Not having a storage location for it is really the least of my concerns. I love the size of this sheet pan! It is honestly my first go-to pan now. I expect it to see a lot of usage in my house!
✔ Verified Purchase
D
Daniella
October 28, 2025
The Cookie Sheet of My Dreams (and Possibly My Entire Countertop)
This Cookie Sheet and Cooling Grid Set deserves its own Hallmark movie.First off — XL is not an exaggeration. When they say “extra large,” they mean “clear your entire counter and possibly half your sink” large. This thing could double as a sled in the winter or a shield during a medieval reenactment. I actually had to check twice that it would fit in my oven (spoiler: it barely did — I had to do some light cookie sheet Tetris).But once it was in there… pure cookie perfection. I made an entire batch of chocolate chip cookies in one go — all of them. No more rotating trays or waiting for the next round. I felt like a domestic goddess on a baking competition show, except I was wearing pajama pants and arguing with the dog about who gets the first cookie.The nonstick surface? Unreal. The cookies slid off like they were auditioning for a cooking spray commercial. Even the one that I accidentally overbaked (for “testing purposes”) didn’t cling for dear life. And the cooling rack fits perfectly — like they’re best friends who went to culinary school together.By the time I was done, my kitchen smelled like a bakery, my counters were covered in flour, and my soul was at peace. The only downside is that I’ll never be able to go back to normal-sized cookie sheets again — they feel like Easy Bake Oven toys now.So yes, it’s big. Borderline comically big. But if you want to feel like you’re baking cookies for an army — or at least for your hungry family who acts like one — this is the sheet pan for you. 🍪🔥
✔ Verified Purchase
S
Stephanie H.
February 04, 2026
GoodCook set of 2 pans
Product description is deceiving. It is not a set of 2. It is a 2 piece set!!!!
✔ Verified Purchase
A
Ancient Roots
December 04, 2025
Nice baking sheet for large quantities
This is a great cooking sheet! I’ve used it for cookies, vegetables, and french fries/tater tots. I like that you can cook a lot more at once on this one sheet because it’s so large. It fits perfectly in my oven.The wire rack is super useful for cookies and bread loaves.I’m very happy with it and it seems like a great value.My only complaint is that it’s a little bit hard to clean because it is so large, it doesn’t fit in the sink.
✔ Verified Purchase
M
michael
February 04, 2026
Misleading description
I only gave three stars because, while the products are the quality, the description makes it sound like you're getting two of each because it calls it a set of two. I interpret a set as a cookie sheet AND a cooling rack. Otherwise, it's just a cookie sheet or a cooling rack. Will send back because this is too much to pay for one of each.
✔ Verified Purchase
T
Taylor M
December 07, 2025
Large nonstick sheets that allow large batch cooking
Two large cookie sheets/pans that distribute heat evenly and are coated for nonstick cooking.Easy to clean and store.I love that I can bake large amount of cookies at one time.
✔ Verified Purchase
C
Customer Review
November 07, 2025
Huge pan, good for batch cooking
Oversized sheet pan and rack set that fully fills an oven rack. The pan combo is great for batch cooking, large cookie batches, and meal prep. The elevated grid is useful for cooling or for roasting foods without letting moisture pool—helps maintain la crisp texture. Nonstick coating wipes clean easily and has held up so far. Be aware of how much oven space it occupies; not suited for running multiple pans at once unless you have a very large oven. Overall, strong utility for high-volume cooking and roasting.
✔ Verified Purchase
