Y
Yothsothgoth
December 04, 2025
Basic PB&J cutter. Handwash only and harder to clean than others available.
This style of sandwich cutters is one of the most helpful kitchen gadgets to have for a parent of kids who love uncrustable-style PB&Js. Just beware of wasted bread crusts - so maybe make some croutons?Pros –Making them yourself at home is so much more affordable than from the store. Easy to use – fill middle of sandwich, place, close, done. Cutters are sharp and cut well through the sandwiches and press works ok to keep filling inside. You can also make little pies with these cutters.Cons-The larger square one is a bit of a pain – seems to squish the sandwich before even cutting it. Lots of wasted bread, especially with the round one. These NOT being dishwasher safe like other similar products available is honestly more frustrating than I originally thought. The sealing border isn't very wide, and occasionally I have a sandwich that tries to unseal/fall open/apart.Why I feel these are a 4-star item-The cutters can’t go through the dishwasher to be sanitized, and handwashing of smaller parts (with a sharp metal ring) isn’t my thing. This design flaw makes this cutter kind of gross to me. I prefer another product that I got years ago that is more like a cookie cutter - not only is it dishwasher safe, but it opens completely into 2 pieces (no sharp metal edges either!), has a wider sealing border, and I have no worries about it getting nasty/moldy inside anywhere (hinges or small spaces). IMO, they need to make this able to be taken apart for cleaning and the sealing part needs to be wider to make a better seal.Overall, although the YVREOLP sandwich cutter does the job - there are other products available that are better and are just as or more affordable. I would NOT recommend this product as I was just not a huge fan.
✔ Verified Purchase
Makes School Lunch Prep Quick and Mess-Free
Preparing school lunches has become significantly easier since I started using these sandwich cutters. I found that the two different shapes are perfect for specific types of meals. The circular cutter is my go-to for classic peanut butter and jelly; it seals the edges perfectly so the filling doesn't leak out, which is a major plus for kids who don't like messes. On the other hand, the square cutter is the ideal size for a standard slice of bread with ham and cheese.It removes the crust efficiently while maximizing the amount of sandwich left over. I’ve noticed that the plastic is thick and durable, making it easy to press through multiple layers of bread and meat without much effort. They are also incredibly easy to clean; a quick rinse or a trip through the dishwasher, and they’re ready for the next day. These have turned a mundane morning chore into a quick task, and my kids are much more likely to finish their lunch when it’s presented in such a neat, professional-looking, crustless way.
✔ Verified Purchase
C
Customer
December 28, 2025
Good deal overall.
Overall performance has been reliable, and the construction feels appropriate for regular use. It’s functional and easy to handle.The value is fair for the price. It meets expectations without standing out.
✔ Verified Purchase
So obsessed with these!
I wholeheartedly recommend this for anyone who runs through a seemingly bottomless pit of the freezer brand of crustless sandwiches. The circle and square cutters seal well enough to keep jelly from squeezing out the edges, which is the main reason my kids like it. The cuts are super easy and clean if you use softer bread and don’t overfill the sandwich.The build feels basic but good for the price. It’s easy to rinse off and doesn’t take up much space in the drawer. There’s nothing fancy about it, but it does the job and makes lunches a lot less messy!!!!!
✔ Verified Purchase
Awesome for Crustless, Significant Waste
LOVE the concept, unfortunately it creates a ton of waste regardless of which size (square or round) I use. Most breads are compatible with the round size, but the square is more limited with compatibility. The sandwich presses are super easy to use, but a little annoying to clean (a small brush is included for cleaning, but that doesn't keep it from being an extra chore). I've decided to avoid multiple cleanings by making a batch of sandwiches and freezing the majority like am Uncrustable brand sandwich which is found in the freezer aisle. This helps me save time.My toddlers definitely love eating their sandwiches this way, but I'm not sure what to do about the parts that are discarded to keep my guilt at-bay.
✔ Verified Purchase
D
DebintheD
November 14, 2025
Every mom needs these, grandma too.
If your child loves those little crustless PBJs in the freezer section of the grocery store then you already know how expensive they are. These Sandwich Cutters allow you to make your own inexpensive and probably healthier versions. I use the round one for PBJs and my younger grandkids love them, so easy too. The larger square one is for my husband and I. We have been experimenting and so far it's great for grilled cheese in the air fryer. I've also made tuna salad sandwiches with the large and small cutters. Adjust for bread size. The possibilities are endless. Well designed and crafted with quality materials these should last a long time.
✔ Verified Purchase
Not bad, not perfect
My first test run was Italian sandwich bread (without filling). The square cutter was not big enough to cut and seal all the way around the slices, leaving a crusty gap on one side. Using square sandwich loaves should fit better, but that limits the bread options. The cutter also cut the bread rather raggedy.I put that same empty sandwich into the round cutter, and that did a decent job. However, the waste of bread was eye-opening. The two empty slices totaled 62 grams, and the trimmings from the round cutter weighed 38 grams. That's more than 60% trimmed off. What do people do with the trimmings?I also tested the square cutter on tart pastry. It did a poor job on that, because the pressed edges stretched instead of releasing from the mold, even though I floured it first. I'm hoping to have better luck after chilling the dough.
✔ Verified Purchase
